Pioneer Camp Of The Saints: The 1846 and 1847 Mormon Trail Journals of Thomas Bullock Rating :
Customer Reviews
Most helpful customer reviews
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
The journals are great, but Bagley's commentary is not
By bixodoido
These are the journals of Thomas Bullock: the man commissioned by Brigham Young to write about the first ("Pioneer") company of Mormons to make the trek into Utah. They are written in typical 19th century style--full of and odd anecdotes and more chronologically than organizationally minded. Of course, they are journals, and as such are more concerned with fact than literary style.
The journals themselves are a great insight into the travels of this company. Also, the notes Bagley assembled are great--full of relevant and useful information that greatly enriches the reading of this account. The only flaw is Bagley's own additions.
The first two chapters were written by him, as sort of a preface, and each chapter is prefaced by a few pages of his commentary. These writings detract greatly from the work, and are full of speculations presented as truth and seemingly oblivious to fact. As far as history is concerned, it has very little worth, being more a collection of his opinions than actual circumstance backed by evidence. There is no citation of sources, which further detracts from the credibility.
Overall, these journals are great, and the editing, superb. Just don't rely too much on what Bagley says about them. If you're interested in Mormon or Western history, these journals are worth a read. It won't detract at all from the experience if you skip the prefaces, though.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
Their Grand Trek West
By Just Judy
This book comes with the unexpected bonus of a color map showing the highlights of the Mormon Pioneer Trail and, on the reverse side, a picture filled synopsis of the 1847 trek and the tools of the time.
My understanding of Thomas Bullock and his work was broadened by Mr. Bagley's input before each journal and throughout the book in the form of additional paragraphs and footnotes. Within these pages I found several interesting tables and illustrations as well as a day-by-day recount of what happened on the various Mormon trails. Thomas speaks of the nature and wildlife he encounters as well as the day to day issues of the westward trek.
This book and these journals are a must for every history buff with interest in the development of Mormonism. We are fortunate to have such journals preserved to this day. Thank you Will Bagley and all who made this work available to us--the readers of the world.
Product Description
The official journal of the Brigham Young pioneer company is made available for the first time in this book. The arrival of Latter-day Saints in the Valley of the Great Salt Lake is one of the major events in the history of the LDS church and the West. Thomas Bullock, the author of this account, was the official journal keeper of that party of pioneers.
Bullock was the “Clerk of the Camp of Israel,” an English scribe who is perhaps more responsible than any other person for the vast documentary record of the LDS church in the the mid-nineteenth century. Though he wrote thousands of pages ultimately released under other men’s names, he remains a relatively obscure figure in Western History.
An intensely personal document, Bullock’s account rises above its status as the “official” journal. He shares his doubts, his complaints, his personal assessments of his fellow travelers throughout the pages of the journal. This remarkable record presents in detail the daily reality of a journey that has become an American legend.
From Nauvoo to Salt Lake and back to the Missouri River, Bullock’s journals from September 1846 to October 1847 paint a colorful and personal picture of both the Mormon Trail and the suffering of the poverty-stricken Saints during their struggle across Iowa in 1846. They tell the legendary tale of Brigham Young’s pioneer company–the beginning of a great exodus across the Plains and Rockies to the Great Basin Kingdom.
Life at Winter Quarters, the renowned “miracle of the Quail” at the Poor Camp on the Mississippi River, detailed accounts of buffalo hunts, dances and celebrations, and other trail events are recorded.
Jim Bridger’s famous meeting with Brigham Young and other leaders of the pioneer party was described in detail by Bullock. Bridger’s comments on the Valley of the Great Salt Lake, the Indians, agriculture and the West in general show the breadth of knowledge of mountain men like Bridger. The interview also gives evidence of the unanswered questions still plaguing the Saints as they neared their destination.
With maps, illustrations, bibliography and index, this work is a major contribution to the history of overland migration, the LDS church, and the wider West. The book provides insight into the impressions of a devout European immigrant of the great American West. An appendix containing biographical data on Mormon pioneers is included.
Product Details
- Amazon Sales Rank: #2446781 in Books
- Published on: 2001-04-01
- Original language:English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.06" h x6.06" w x1.26" l,1.42 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 400 pages
No comments :
Post a Comment